More Attacks, More Oil

October brought more attacks on shipping at Hormuz than any month of the war and more tanker transits, and the world oil market moved back into surplus. Three more tankers were hit on 15 and 16 November and Brent closed 3.6 percent lower.

October brought more attacks on shipping at Hormuz than any month of the war and more tanker transits, and the world oil market moved back into surplus. Three more tankers were hit on 15 and 16 November and Brent closed 3.6 percent lower. The attacks burden Gulf oil with cost and delay without reversing its recovery, and a sinking, a verified mine or a lost week of transits would show that changing.

On Sunday 15 November a projectile damaged the steering gear of the Al Dhannah, a supertanker linked to Abu Dhabi's state oil company, and the ship turned back toward Dubai. On Monday two more tankers were hit in the Strait of Hormuz. Both suffered engine-room fires. One was left disabled about seven nautical miles north of Khasab. The British maritime trade office that logged all three named no attacker. Iran's Revolutionary Guards claimed far more, saying six tankers had caught fire on mines over the two days, and nobody has verified that.

Brent crude closed that Monday down 3.6 percent at 92.44 dollars.

October set the pattern. A shipping intelligence service counted 37 confirmed attacks that month, the most of the war, with eleven supertankers damaged by the 23rd. The same month brought 449 tanker transits of the strait, up from 413 in September and 323 in August. Ships with no Iranian link made 418 of them, the highest monthly total since the war began on 28 February. Gulf crude exports reached 15 million barrels a day, 82 percent of the pre-war rate. Observed stocks worldwide rose by 52 million barrels. The International Energy Agency reported supply ahead of demand for the first time since the war began. It now expects a surplus of 1.7 million barrels a day this quarter, where it had forecast a deficit. North Sea crude has dropped from 136 dollars on 8 October to about 93, still 22 dollars above its pre-war level.

The attacks cost a great deal all the same, and no published series shows what the Gulf would have shipped without them. Total Gulf oil exports sit 26 percent below their pre-war level. Refined products and liquefied petroleum gas leave the Gulf at about half the old rate. European diesel trades near 180 dollars a barrel, some 77 percent above its pre-war price. Freight from the Gulf to Asia stays close to record. Vessel traffic through the strait runs roughly 65 percent below normal. About 227 ships wait at anchorages east of it. At least one seafarer has been killed this month.

The recovery has a method. Tankers cross with their tracking signals switched off, as two of the ships hit in these two days had done for weeks. They hand cargoes to other vessels in the Gulf of Oman. None of the seven tankers attacked in the trade office's latest weekly count was reported sunk, and three sailed on. Hulls are damaged and owners keep sending ships.

Three explanations share the falling price, and the record cannot yet rank them. Supply has come back. Demand has shrunk, by about 3 million barrels a day on one large trader's estimate, so part of the surplus is oil the world stopped buying. Prices have also slid since the American midterm elections of 3 November, as Washington held back from new strikes on Iran. The slide began before this weekend's attacks, and three weeks ago the record attack month and a six-month high in futures arrived together.

The test is whether a burst of attacks can still turn the price. One large bank sees that risk in the near term, and the energy agency calls maritime security pivotal to a sustained recovery. A sunk supertanker, a verified mine in the southern lane or a week of transits lost on the scale of early October would each show the attacks reversing the flow again. Until then the measured effect of the campaign is a higher cost of moving Gulf oil, alongside volumes that grew through its heaviest month.