Fifteen Deadlines
Russia's demand for the rest of Donetsk is the one obstacle Washington names to a settlement, and the army meant to take that territory has fallen years behind the timetable it promised.
Russia's demand for the rest of Donetsk is the one obstacle Washington names to a settlement, and the army meant to take that territory has fallen years behind the timetable it promised. The talks that opened in Miami on Friday centre on a truce over energy strikes that would cost Kyiv its attacks on Russian refineries. Whether Moscow's road to Donetsk still runs through the ground war is the question this winter will answer.
In the year to 1 October Russian forces took about 630 square kilometres of Donetsk Oblast. Some 5,382 remain in Ukrainian hands, including the four cities of the Fortress Belt, Sloviansk, Kramatorsk, Druzhkivka and Kostyantynivka. At last year's pace that is more than eight years of fighting. Putin has set at least fifteen deadlines for taking Donbas since 2022 and missed every one. In May his commanders reportedly told him the whole region could be taken by this autumn. The newest deadline has reportedly slipped to spring 2027, which would need more than ten times last year's rate.
The plan to close that gap was a wide encirclement, with one pincer reaching down from Lyman in the north and another climbing from Dobropillya in the southwest. A Ukrainian counteroffensive north of Lyman has broken up the northern arm. The corps commander there claims 176 square kilometres retaken in three phases, and Russian military bloggers now concede Ukrainian advances east of Sloviansk and Kramatorsk. On Thursday a Russian bomb killed 30 people on two buses in Kramatorsk.
The ground war still carries danger for Kyiv. Russian troops have made real gains inside Kostyantynivka, the drive toward Dobropillya continues and senior commanders are said to be pressing for a large mobilization that could change the arithmetic. Fortified cities rarely fall at an average pace.
The diplomacy has stood still while the map moved. Marco Rubio called the war a strategic stalemate on Thursday and named Russia's demand for all of Donbas as the reason he sees no prospect of a negotiated settlement. A day earlier Moscow's deputy foreign minister said no American-mediated talks with Ukraine were planned. The Kremlin has made a Ukrainian withdrawal from the region its condition since at least May.
Miami deals in something more tractable. Washington's envoys are meeting Kyiv's negotiators and then European and NATO officials on security guarantees, reconstruction and a truce covering energy infrastructure and the Black Sea. The most public American request of Kyiv this autumn has been to stop hitting Russian diesel refineries, which the White House blames for a fuel shortage the war with Iran also feeds. Russian diesel exports have fallen to about a fifth of their five-year average. Kyiv says it will stop only if Russia stops striking Ukraine's grid.
Two readings remain open. In one, Russia's demand has outlived the military route to it, and Moscow will eventually have to trade for the territory or let the claim lapse. In the other, the ground war was never the main road. Russia's long-range campaign against Ukrainian power, heat and water, together with Washington's interest in cheaper diesel before its midterm elections, presses on Kyiv harder than any offensive in Donetsk, and the demand stays on the table until one of them works.
The coming months will separate them. A mobilization order or the fall of Kostyantynivka would revive the ground route. An energy truce that halts the refinery strikes while the territorial demand stands unchanged would show where the leverage went.