The Truce Moscow Has Not Signed
Washington eased sanctions on Russian diesel two days before announcing an energy ceasefire that only Kyiv has accepted, and only on condition that Moscow does the same. In September the Kremlin named sanctions relief as one condition of exactly such a truce.
Washington eased sanctions on Russian diesel two days before announcing an energy ceasefire that only Kyiv has accepted, and only on condition that Moscow does the same. In September the Kremlin named sanctions relief as one condition of exactly such a truce. Moscow now holds part of what it asked for and has said nothing, and Russian strikes hit Ukrainian power plants on the truce's first evening.
On Sunday evening Donald Trump announced that Russia and Ukraine had agreed to stop attacking each other's energy systems, effective immediately. He gave no details and added "Do not break it!" Within hours Volodymyr Zelensky reported a drone strike on a power plant in Kyiv and attacks on energy facilities around Kharkiv, and his office confirmed the Kharkiv strike came after the post. Kyiv said it would hold fire on Russian energy if Moscow did the same. Moscow said nothing.
The announcement capped a weekend that began with a different deal. On Friday Trump said Vladimir Putin would release 300,000 tonnes of diesel at once and 500,000 more in November, and the Treasury issued a temporary licence for Russian diesel that reportedly suspends sanctions until 7 April. A US official said the decision followed Zelensky ignoring about half a dozen requests to stop striking Russian refineries. Washington blames those strikes for American diesel prices, which peaked above six and a half dollars a gallon in September. They also drove Russia to ban its own diesel exports, tightening a market the Iran war had already squeezed.
The cost showed up in Miami. Ukrainian negotiators spent Friday with Washington's envoys and European officials on security guarantees, territory and reconstruction. They were told of the diesel decision during the talks. The meeting ended a day early and the delegation headed home. On Saturday Trump said Ukraine needed a new president. On Sunday seven senators, four of them Republicans, called the deal a breach of the 2022 ban on Russian energy imports.
The record behind the truce matters. Trump announced a similar understanding on 14 September and nothing followed. The next day the Kremlin called the idea "very good" and named two conditions: safe passage for its tankers and the lifting of sanctions on Russian energy. Four weeks later one of those conditions has been partly met by licence. Russia has neither accepted the truce nor stopped striking the Ukrainian grid, and its winter plan, as described in a leaked document, targets substations and the interconnectors that carry European power into Ukraine.
Two readings fit the facts. In the first, the licence is an advance on a truce Moscow has yet to accept, and the test is whether Russian strikes on Ukrainian generation stop in the coming days. In the second, the licence is a fuel-price measure ahead of the November midterms, and the truce is a parallel effort Washington wants for the same reason, since its most visible demand of Kyiv this autumn has been to leave Russian refineries alone. Ukraine meanwhile keeps hitting Russian targets outside the energy sector, including three Yandex data centres in four days.
Which reading holds will show quickly. A Kremlin statement accepting the truce, a pause in Russian strikes on power plants or a Ukrainian refinery strike after Sunday would each settle part of it. For now the energy truce carries one conditional signature, and the licence has already been issued.